Death & Dying

Gretchen’s Eulogy for Stellajoe

(You can listen to this here, but the first several paragraphs are missing.)

The past nearly six years were some of the hardest of my life. That I thought I was sacrificing my independence to take care of my mother, and that she seemed to think I was coming to be taken care of, was a constant source of conflict. It was only later I realized I had disrupted her independence too. And while I would get mine back, she would not. She was fighting her last battle: old age. And it would take massive courage.

When I arrived, she had been intrepidly navigating her life alone for 17 years after my father died. True, Rebecca had been helping her for the last ten, and grandson Joel lived with her briefly, and then there I was. I wonder if she lived to nearly 102 because she had all these darned children to take care of.

But her courage did not begin in 1995 when she suddenly lost her husband. It began back in the 1930s rural south when she survived childhood in a challenged family, spoke out against racism in a “senior sermon” at her church, and was the first in her family to attend college.

She hiked in a skirt in her beloved Smoky Mountains with her girlfriends, and later with the Michigander who would become her husband. When I unearthed and read the 600 surviving letters they wrote to each other during WWII, I learned some new things about her pluck.

She didn’t expect she would marry, didn’t think anyone would want her. Then along came George, handsome and smart and kind. And completely smitten with her. As I sat in the early morning dark, I read letter after letter in which he agonized over her refusal to say she loved him. Finally, at wit’s end, he nearly ended the relationship because he figured she must not.

“Why wouldn’t you tell him?” I asked her, aching on his behalf 75 years later, 51 of which they were married.

“I guess because we hardly knew each other,” she finally said, after a pause so long I thought she wasn’t going to respond. “He was the first man I’d dated; and we had never been on a date alone. A courtship by mail seemed artificial.”

Wow, I thought, here was her ticket to a better life than she ever dreamed of, and she had the wisdom to take time to examine her own heart and be sure before she leaped.

While George was at New York University in officer training as the war in Europe escalated, Stellajoe decided she needed to leave her job as secretary to the director at the Tennessee Valley Authority and do something she felt would contribute to ending the conflict. She had long been fascinated with the territory of Alaska. She studied for and took the Civil Service exam, then requested an appointment to an air base in Alaska or Washington. She didn’t consult her best friend, her parents, or George. When she was assigned to Geiger Field in Spokane, she announced her plan, packed a footlocker, and adventurously crossed the country by train at the age of 26. She arrived knowing no one and with no place to stay. She found a room in a rooming house and went to work.

She hated Spokane, so seven months later, when George finished training and was stationed in Dallas, where he figured he would sit out the war, he made a rare phone call to her.

“Do you wanna get married?” he asked. (That’s how she told me he asked.)

She said yes, bought a wedding dress, packed her footlocker, and boarded a train again. They were married a week later. I guess she decided she loved him.

Six weeks later he got marching orders—he was going to Europe after all.

Stellajoe moved to Michigan to live with his family. It took a new kind of courage to live with the strong mother-in-law she barely knew, but she loved his family, including her young niece and nephew. They listened to war news each evening gathered around the radio. She and her sister-in-law Ruth embroidered pillow cases and wrote and received hundreds of letters that took weeks to crisscross the ocean between them and their husbands.

Stellajoe got a position at the University of Michigan School of Forestry where George had been a student, until once more she decided it was too frivolous a job in the face of the turmoil her husband, brother, brother-in-law, and sister-in-law were in the midst of. She got another Civil Service job at the Housing Authority nearby. After a year in Michigan, she moved to Florida to live with her parents—driving George’s Ford on rationed rubber tires—where she worked at another air field. She remained there until George returned.

Other than the six weeks in Texas, she had seen him three brief times since he enlisted 3-1/2 years earlier.

I know all of this, of course, only from story. My experience of her until I returned to live with her, was not of a courageous woman. Sadly, I hardly knew her during the 3-1/2 decades we spent on opposite coasts. It’s only now that she is gone and the hard years for both of us are over, that I recognize the courage she continued to have.

She was an introvert, and yet when she saw something that needed to be done, she summoned strength from deep inside and, with great humility, did it. She spoke out for world peace. She became an advocate for issues faced by the aging. And she often defied George in her passions, or dragged him along for the ride. We all know how she led the charge to save the hill behind our home, standing up to her trees-are-a-renewable-resource forester husband and facing city officials. She joined the Sierra Club, which George abhorred, boldly putting a bumper sticker on the car. Born before women gained the right to vote, she voted her own conscience in every presidential election from Franklin Roosevelt to Hillary Clinton—which thrilled her—often cancelling out my father’s vote.

I had one more question about going against her husband’s beliefs, and I asked it:

“Would you have been so accepting of your gay daughters and grandchildren if he had not died?”

“Oh,” she said, uncharacteristically quickly, “he would have come around. I would have persuaded him.”

I didn’t know she had that kind of influence. After he died, she left membership in the church they had known for decades to join this one because of its passion for social justice.

After George’s death—I only recently realized because I hadn’t been paying attention—she did not ask her daughters for help in negotiating the river of things that have to be done when a loved one dies. As my sisters and I did the tasks together following her death, I could not comprehend how she did it alone. Later, she did not ask advice about staying in the house, nor for decision-making help in its maintenance. She never asked us to come home and help her. I’m sure she didn’t want to disrupt our lives; and she was a do-it-myself person. That apple didn’t fall far.

She called her 80s her favorite decade. “Why?” I asked. She was 79 when my father died, so it was curious to me. She didn’t use these words, but the sentiment is the same; “I got my mojo back when I was alone and had to fend for myself.”

I don’t think she thought of herself as brave, and—as Queen of Worry— there was much she was afraid of. But as she arrived upon each daunting task, she faced it down and beat it. Not the least of which were the health issues—literally from head to toe—that dogged her and that she dogged many doctors about, refusing to accept that they were a product of old age. She wanted a name and a fix, preferably without drugs or surgery, and she was, by golly, going to get it. She railed at doctors who told her she was “doing well for her age.” One of the last recorded books she listened to, at age 100, was a two-parter on the life-styles of the world’s oldest living people, hoping to learn something. My sisters and I express our gratitude to every health care professional over the years for their patience in her pursuit of the fountain of youth.

Losing her vision was the most significant of her health issues. Last month, I ran across one of her prolific writings on scraps of paper in which she wrote many years ago that blindness was the thing she most feared. Indeed, she worried about it for three decades. Consuming foods containing vitamin K, wearing hats with visors, and using non-generic, preservative-free eye drops probably preserved it as long as possible. But when she finally outlived her eyes, which would have put most of us under, she faced it with courage. Not without constant talk about it, but she kept on keeping on. If she had had her vision at 100, she would have been unstoppable.

I never thought of myself as courageous either. But I see now the many times I have done and continue to do brave things. Without even knowing it, she was my shining example. And it took being here observing her to see it.

I also learned to love the natural world from her. From the dish gardens we made together when I was a child to selling American Seeds and planting nasturtiums in my first childhood garden, to my love of hiking mountain trails, to my finally-developing curiosity about what is happening in the woods behind our home—and writing about and photographing it all—I have her to thank.

She loved spring, not only because of the stark contrast to the Pacific Northwest season called Gray, which she detested, but because of the persistence of each bird and blossom to bounce back to life in hopeful exuberance. She always bounced back then too. I’m glad she left us just as her beloved dogwood and trillium were in bloom, as the lilacs filled the air with sweet scent, as the fiddle heads on the sword fern unfurled. I hope she can see them now.

She loved the Pacific Northwest and her beloved Appalachians differently—and she instilled in me a love of both. She reveled in hearing stories of my hiking and camping adventures, while admiring—and fearing—my courage to go it alone. “Got that from you,” I would say. Her love of nature and these two ecologies is a love she passed to me, to my children, and is being gifted to theirs. I hope my own great-grandchildren will learn the story of their ancestor’s love of this beautiful world and carry on with her in their hearts.

I want to thank a few people for their care of both my mother and me these past years. To the cadre of people whose help with the property made it possible for her to stay in her home, especially to Dan—she loved you so much—and to Chris whose help I rely on still. To her beautiful friends who loyally visited her. To Providence Hospice, oh my god, we cannot express our gratitude enough. To David, the elder care social worker who assured me again and again that this is hard work and that I was a good person and would not go crazy. And to her caregivers: the staff at Cook’s Hill Manor; to Kim, Bonnie, Jill, and Jill who also cared for me, and especially to Michelle. She loved you like a daughter; otherwise it wouldn’t have been so contentious at times. To Emma and Wynne who brought balance in my life by letting me take care of their babies, who also made their Nana-great so happy. To Jo Ann, who crossed the country so I could cross in the other direction to see my other two grandsons. And to Rebecca: I could not and would not have done this without you. Do you know how many stars are in the sky? I love you more than that. And so did Mama.

In my mother’s courage to face whatever came and to watch carefully the natural world, though only a part of who she was, she had an overarching curiosity about the world and everything in it. I read this quote by Elizabeth Gilbert to her some time back, because, I told her, I thought she inhabited it:

“You might spend your whole life following your curiosity and have absolutely nothing to show for it at the end—except one thing. You will have the satisfaction of knowing that you passed your entire existence in devotion to inquisitiveness. And that should be more than enough for anyone to say that they lived a rich and splendid life.”

She had much to show for her life, but by that definition, my mother did indeed have a rich and splendid life, and she thought so too. She claimed in recent years, not to believe in heaven. “I’ve had an abundant life,” she told me, “I don’t deserve or need anything more.” My father didn’t believe in a life after death either. When he died without warning, I wanted so desperately to know I would see him again. I asked my minister what happens when a person who doesn’t believe in heaven dies. “I guess,” he said, “they are surprised.”

I hope my mother is hiking through wildflowers and old growth forests and stream-laced mountain meadows with her true love.

Gretchen and Stellajoe.jpg

Jo Ann’s eulogy, Rebecca’s eulogy. Emma’s eulogy.


5 thoughts on “Gretchen’s Eulogy for Stellajoe”

  1. They are all beautiful eulogies, and fitting tributes to such a remarkable woman. She and your dad would be immensely proud.


  2. As a middle child I understand quite well that particularly challenging mother/daughter dynamic. I like to think your Mom needed a challenge and found it easily in you. The story you have told the past few years has been honest and insightful and you told it with humor and with love. Your eulogy was beautiful, as was the service. It felt like a door gently closing. Thank you for sharing this extraordinary part of your life. Somehow I feel like a better human for having heard it ♡


    1. It just occurred to me this very moment that my mother was also a middle child. There was one half sibling still at home, then her mother’s first born, and two younger siblings. Huh, I have never once thought about that.

      Thank you for coming to the service, and for your appreciation. We worked hard on it. I’m sorry it’s over in a way. It felt like a gift, of which I was both giver and recipient. 💜

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I will read through these Eulogies more carefully upon my return from my vacation. I will say, already, that I am excited about doing so. You have a gift for sharing a very honest and personal narration.

    With Respect,


    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s